Proposal for new StarFrontiersman process

CleanCutRogue's picture
CleanCutRogue
March 17, 2008 - 6:39am

Proposed Workflow
There are really only two types of submissions I get: Art (seldom, but look at the gems I got from Corjay and Shell for issue 8) and Articles.  I get these in all different formats and all forms.  I can pretty much work with anything, but some types of submissions are honestly easier to work with than others.  I also get them in many different ways: links to content on this site, emails with .doc or .rtf attachments, .txt files, PMs, emails, heck, I've even received autocad drawings.  This all needs to be streamlined and simplified.

  • Art. All Art submissions should be in .png format, with a resolution of at minimum 150 dpi (.png isn't compressed, meaning the file will be quite large, but it allows me to decide on compression versus quality -- there have been some maps and submitted art that has been less than attractive in the issues because of compressing compression).  They should be emailed as attachments to Submissions@StarFrontiersman.com (an email address I'll create).  The email must include the name by which the artist would like to be credited and a valid return email address.
  • Articles. All Article submissions should be double spaced and in .doc format.  Please use default template formatting (don't change fonts, sizes, colors, use columns, etc.) and simple unthemed tables.  Article submissions may, if desired, use headings of level 1, 2, or 3, and otherwise Plain Text.  They should be emailed as attachments to Submissions@StarFrontiersman.com.  The body of the email must include the author's real name and email address, a one-line description of the article, and the name by which the author wishes to be credited in the byline of the article.

 

Cardinal Rules for All Editors: we want to use every submission and we want to include every submitter.  That doesn’t mean everyone’s stuff is good, but work with them until it is good.  Treat every submitter with respect and friendliness.  We’re assembling fan-based goodness.  If we lose the submitters because they felt poorly received, it will end this webzine.


Submission Editor
The Submission Editor will have access to Submissions@StarFrontiersman.com and must be able to check it regularly (I can help you set up outlook express, outlook, thunderbird, etc.).  He/she will perform front-line triage on the submissions, making sure the article is usable or the artwork tasteful.  May build a rapport with the submitters, praising them for what they do well, encouraging them to submit more of what they do well at, giving ideas on avenues to further develop.  Submission Editor may also probe known submitters for material, asking for ideas or even specific types of articles.  It's important for the Submission Editor to drum up more submissions!  When he receives a submission of artwork or article that he's happy about, he'll go to a special page on the site that he'll have access to (this site or over at starfrontiersman.com, not sure yet), fill out a web form (author's name, email address, credit in byline, date, notes from submission editor, and a place to attach/upload the submission).  If it's an artwork submission, he'll fill out an Artwork web form.  Otherwise, an Article web form.  Then he's done with it... continues working on other submissions or actively working on getting submissions from others.

Art Editor
The art editor will have access to a special page on the site where he'll have a list of artwork submitted by the submissions editor.  He'll also have access to submit artwork, using the same form as the submission editor (not because he doesn't need the submission editor, but because he may be adding his own as well).  The Art Editor must also have the time on his hands necessary to probe art gallery sites like I have over this past year to get permission to use all the great artwork I've obtained for covers.  Sometimes, a request might come to the Art editor (he'll have an @starfrontiersman.com email address too) from the line editor or the Referee (me!) for a specific piece of art.  It's the Art Editor's job to try to work with the artists we often work with (line art for equipment is mostly me, Corjay does great inks and a few other mediums, and Shell does what looks like a mixed medium that has a unique style) to produce specific pieces of art at request.  The Art Editor maintains a database of submitted art, on the site, that he can produce at the drop of a hat.  Of course, he also has to keep track of who has given permission to use what... it's a big job!

Line Editor
Believe it or not, this is probably the least time-demanding job of all.  A line editor will have access to a special page on the site where he'll have a list of articles submitted by the submissions editor.  He'll be in charge of editing the document, drawing conclusions where he must, changing what he must, communicating with the author where he must, to finally approve the article by changing its status from "submitted" to "edited"  The Line Editor must make sure the article is usable and fits in the Star Frontiers setting.  He must also know when diagrams or artwork might make something more clear or of superior quality.  If the rules presented in the article need playtest, he must be able to test them either in a play group or by himself with simulated gaming (dice and paper, like normal).  The line editor is not rewriting the article, just helping it become all that it can be.  Some submitters over the years have needed nearly no editing for neither content nor grammar.  Some have been quite the opposite.  All have been great, though, in the end.

Referee (a.k.a. Chief Editor)
First of all, I plan on being a prolific submitter, going through the normal channels as everyone else.  Second of all, I'll have access to the artwork library and the "edited" submissions library, and will be adding content to the layout as it's edited (not necessarily in the order it's edited, though).  I'll also provide a helping hand to the other editors as needed.  When enough material is gathered to release the issue (very subjective... 70 pages isn't necessary every time, though I don't like the idea of falling much below 48), I'll perform final assembly, do the classifieds (I like those), build the front page from artwork submissions, and finally release it. 

Final Notes
As the webzine grows, I can eventually see adding a fifth position, Public Relations Manager - in charge of pimping and distribution.  Perhaps later, if things get big enough, more positions will become necessary.  right now I can already see I've divided things fairly equally (though I have admittedly given myself a very light role while still maintaining an authoritative position... I hope nobody is bothered by that.)  I'm eager to see what you all think.  This is just my initial thought, so I'm willing to bend until I break on many of the concepts.

3. We wear sungoggles during the day. Not because the sun affects our vision, but when you're cool like us the sun shines all the time.

-top 11 reasons to be a Yazirian, ShadowShack

Comments:

Rum Rogue's picture
Rum Rogue
March 17, 2008 - 9:51am

Very nice breakdown.  Good guidlines.

I can help do some proofreading.  My grammar and diction aint the greatest.  But I am willing to help assist someone in this.

the only hangup at this time, though, is I have a wedding to (assist) plan, and it aint going so well at this time.

Time flies when your having rum.

Im a government employee, I dont goof-off. I constructively abuse my time.

Gergmaster's picture
Gergmaster
March 17, 2008 - 10:52am
Yeah like I said in the email I sent you CleanCut I can help get you submissions with art and what not and help get things going. But, if you read my ezine my english isnt the best but I can write some what at least.
Confucious Says:
     Man with one chopstick go hungry.
     Man who eat many prunes get good run for money.
     Man who live in glass house should change clothes in basement.

Corvus's picture
Corvus
March 17, 2008 - 11:30am
I will do what I can, as always.
If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe. -- Carl Sagan

Sam's picture
Sam
March 17, 2008 - 11:51am

You can count on my help. Free time to do so is, of course, the only real issue.


CleanCutRogue's picture
CleanCutRogue
March 17, 2008 - 11:54am
Since I'm asking for such specific info in the "body of the email" from the submitter, I initially thought it would be best to make a web form, complete with upload spot, with all the fields I'm asking for, then have the site generate that email to get the ball rolling.  At first I was going to have it all be site-based, but I figured some folks don't use this site, and don't want to.  Having submissions be email based is probably best, like I described above.

Alternatively, I could make the submissions form on the www.starfrontiersman.com site - in fact I could make a simple-interface non-complicated site at www.starfrontiersman.com JUST for the webzine workflow and downloads.  Thoughts on this?
3. We wear sungoggles during the day. Not because the sun affects our vision, but when you're cool like us the sun shines all the time.

-top 11 reasons to be a Yazirian, ShadowShack


Anonymous's picture
Corjay (not verified)
March 17, 2008 - 12:04pm
That sounds good. You should offer an email as an option, in case despite that they still prefer email.

Corvus's picture
Corvus
March 17, 2008 - 2:41pm
CleanCutRogue wrote:
At first I was going to have it all be site-based, but I figured some folks don't use this site, and don't want to.


Tongue out Wink

I say, don't try to fancy things up just to be fancy.  Stick with email.
If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe. -- Carl Sagan

CleanCutRogue's picture
CleanCutRogue
March 17, 2008 - 7:12pm
Corvus wrote:
CleanCutRogue wrote:
At first I was going to have it all be site-based, but I figured some folks don't use this site, and don't want to.


Tongue out Wink

I say, don't try to fancy things up just to be fancy. Stick with email.
That thought wasn't to be fancy.  It was so that all the info I need can be submitted to me.  It gets frustrating when I get a submission from "falconcooldude101010@someplace.net" or whatever and he doesn't give me his name, how he wants credited, etc.  Ya know?
3. We wear sungoggles during the day. Not because the sun affects our vision, but when you're cool like us the sun shines all the time.

-top 11 reasons to be a Yazirian, ShadowShack


Corvus's picture
Corvus
March 17, 2008 - 11:23pm
CleanCutRogue wrote:
It gets frustrating when I get a submission from "falconcooldude101010@someplace.net" or whatever and he doesn't give me his name, how he wants credited, etc. Ya know?


Then you:

1.) send an email back saying "I need this information",

or

2.) set aside the noble but ultimately futile effort to be "all-inclusive" and let the guy's submission rot because he's a dum-dum.  This would more likely be after you tried 1.) and he didn't reply.

Besides, if somebody else is taking submissions now, it won't be your headache. Wink
If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe. -- Carl Sagan

CleanCutRogue's picture
CleanCutRogue
March 18, 2008 - 12:41am
Just trying to help make the process better, that's all
3. We wear sungoggles during the day. Not because the sun affects our vision, but when you're cool like us the sun shines all the time.

-top 11 reasons to be a Yazirian, ShadowShack


Anonymous's picture
Corjay (not verified)
March 18, 2008 - 6:28am
I like your idea, Bill, and I think you should do it. What I was saying is giving the option to email if someone is more comfortable with it, giving them clear directions about what information to send where you post the email address.

Will's picture
Will
March 21, 2008 - 12:45pm
I'll lend a hand where needed.

"You're everything that's base in humanity," Cochrane continued. "Drawing up strict, senseless rules for the sole reason of putting you at the top and excluding anyone you say doesn't belong or fit in, for no other reason than just because you say so."


—Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stephens, Federation

CleanCutRogue's picture
CleanCutRogue
March 21, 2008 - 6:48pm
Does anyone want to volunteer to write a "Submission Guideline" document?  I've personally never seen one before so I don't know how one should be formatted.  I'm interested in having something which covers the bases for both Art and Article submissions:

Art submissions should be at least 150dpi resolution, be "family friendly", and preferably in PNG format.  Article submissions should be done in .doc or .rtf format, have minimal formatting, using only simple tables and headings of levels 1, 2, or 3, and should be double-spaced.  All submissions should include: Submitter's Name, email address, one-line description, desired byline, and an attached submission.  All submissions should be sent to Submissions@StarFrontiersman.com.

That's pretty much all I'm looking for... or would that simple paragraph be enough?
3. We wear sungoggles during the day. Not because the sun affects our vision, but when you're cool like us the sun shines all the time.

-top 11 reasons to be a Yazirian, ShadowShack


Anonymous's picture
Corjay (not verified)
March 21, 2008 - 7:39pm
A submission guideline is simply a statement of what you're looking for.

What you posted in your original post is a submission guideline, just add "family friendly" in the art submission:

CleanCutRogue wrote:
  • Art. All Art submissions should be in .png format and "family friendly", with a resolution of at minimum 150 dpi (.png isn't compressed, meaning the file will be quite large, but it allows me to decide on compression versus quality -- there have been some maps and submitted art that has been less than attractive in the issues because of compressing compression).  They should be emailed as attachments to Submissions@StarFrontiersman.com (an email address I'll create).  The email must include the name by which the artist would like to be credited and a valid return email address.
  • Articles. All Article submissions should be double spaced and in .doc or .rtf format.  Please use default template formatting (don't change fonts, sizes, colors, use columns, etc.) and simple unthemed tables.  Article submissions may, if desired, use headings of level 1, 2, or 3, and otherwise Plain Text.  They should be emailed as attachments to Submissions@StarFrontiersman.com.  The body of the email must include the author's real name and email address, a one-line description of the article, and the name by which the author wishes to be credited in the byline of the article.

There's really nothing more you can do. However, there's one thing missing from the art submission: it needs a minimum image size.

TerlObar's picture
TerlObar
March 21, 2008 - 8:03pm
I agree with Corjay, your original statement was dead on execpt for the "family friendly" part.  There is not much else to say.  The minimum image size is a good idea as well as it doesn't do to have a 1"x 1" image at 150 DPI when you need it to fill up 4".  It's just as bad as having it too compressed.

BTW, PNG is a compressed image format.  However, it is a "lossless" compression meaning no information is lost about the individual pixels (like GIF files, which it was designed to replace since GIF is a proprietary format).  JPG's on the other hand use a "lossy" compression and pixel data is smeared out into neighboring pixels.  That is how they get their smaller size, they are throwing away information.  PNG's are still smaller than a pure bitmap, sometimes significantly, but they are typically somewhat larger than a JPG of the same image.
Ad Astra Per Ardua!
My blog - Expanding Frontier
Webmaster - The Star Frontiers Network & this site
Founding Editor - The Frontier Explorer Magazine
Managing Editor - The Star Frontiersman Magazine

Will's picture
Will
March 22, 2008 - 9:01am
CleanCutRogue wrote:
Does anyone want to volunteer to write a "Submission Guideline" document?  I've personally never seen one before so I don't know how one should be formatted.  I'm interested in having something which covers the bases for both Art and Article submissions:

Art submissions should be at least 150dpi resolution, be "family friendly", and preferably in PNG format.  Article submissions should be done in .doc or .rtf format, have minimal formatting, using only simple tables and headings of levels 1, 2, or 3, and should be double-spaced.  All submissions should include: Submitter's Name, email address, one-line description, desired byline, and an attached submission.  All submissions should be sent to Submissions@StarFrontiersman.com.

That's pretty much all I'm looking for... or would that simple paragraph be enough?


That simple paragraph says it all. Why reinvent the wheel?
 

"You're everything that's base in humanity," Cochrane continued. "Drawing up strict, senseless rules for the sole reason of putting you at the top and excluding anyone you say doesn't belong or fit in, for no other reason than just because you say so."


—Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stephens, Federation